PG, City of Homes • July 4, 2026

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: Mrs. B.L. Hollenbeck 1888

118 Caledonia Avenue

Between Central Avenue and Union Street
4 beds, 3.5 baths, 2,300 SF on a 3,037 SF lot
Built, 1880
Last sold, 2008

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

The Caledonia homes encircling the park have Retreat-era lot patterns, visible in their spacing, setbacks, and impressive front yards. This Folk Victorian-influenced vernacular home is the second built on its lot and one of the neighborhood’s oldest survivors.

Building History

 

Facing the park, the frontage opens onto a public green space with a free-play area, tots’ area, ADA-compliant playground equipment, climbing equipment, a baseball field, a basketball court, picnic tables, and restrooms. The park stretches between Central and Jewell Avenues, so the house looks directly across to a broad, active open area rather than to another line of houses.

 

That gives the front of the property a long, open outlook and a view across a place built for children, gathering, and recreation.

The front elevation climbs in steps: retaining wall, planting, brick stairs, railings, porch, then entry.

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

That upward movement is the main front-facing feature, with the porch sitting above street level and the planted foreground softening the base of the façade.

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

The tall left-side volume, centered porch, and the layered approach from sidewalk to entry aligns very different styles within the facade while showcasing each update.

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

The font shows Victorian-era elements in the gable form, asymmetrical massing, shingle treatment, and porch-front composition.

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

Those features sit alongside later expansions, especially in the taller left-side mass, which changes the overall shape and size of the house and gives it a bigger front elevation. The result is a house with older stylistic elements still visible in a form that has been adjusted to suit the times.

 

Pacific Grove, City of Homes, #39: 118 Caledonia Avenue

 

Three Things I Love About the Home

 

1. The Park
The lot offers front-row access to the playground and creates a more spaced out neighborhood.

 

Caledonia Park

 

2. The Climb
Each level of the stately approach offers something to admire

 

Yard and Cypress Tree

 

3. The Cypress
The massive local tree gives the front yard a deep canopy and visually balances the two-story addition, which together frame the stairs and porch.